You’re not buying customers, you’re buying influence

Is local advertising losing to zero-click search? Eric Shafer of IndoorMedia explains why grocery receipt coupons win on attribution, targeting and ROI.

Local advertisingAttributionZero-click search

You're not buying customers, you're buying influence

Is local advertising losing to zero-click search? Eric Shafer of IndoorMedia explains why grocery receipt coupons win on attribution, targeting and ROI.

Eric Shafer
In conversation withEric ShaferChief Transformation Officer, IndoorMedia
Full transcript 0 chapters
Eric Shafer, Chief Transformation Officer at IndoorMedia, guest on Pathmonk Presents
Watch the full episode Prefer audio? Listen here

“Advertising is a journey. It's not a transaction. You're not buying customers, you're buying influence.”

,
Meet the guest

at

Company
IndoorMedia
Speciality
Coupon ads on grocery receipt tape and brand ads on shopping carts
Works with
Local businesses such as quick-serve restaurants, salons, insurance and real estate agents
Reach
9,000 grocery stores across the US and Canada
Growth engine
A 500-person sales team plus close to $100,000 a month in digital ads
Episode brief

Too long, didn’t listen?

Eric Shafer, Chief Transformation Officer at IndoorMedia, explains how the company has spent 37 years helping local businesses reach their neighbors. It does this with coupon ads on the back of grocery store receipts and brand ads on shopping carts. He calls the company the shark of advertising because it has offered precise attribution, geographic targeting, exposure and repetition since 1989, right in the shopper's hand.

He compares that with a digital landscape that is getting more expensive and more fragmented because of generative AI and zero-click search. He then lays out a four-legged model for local growth: loyalty, advertising, conversion and nurture. He also explains why customers who renew their receipt ads see 6 to 7 times ROI, and tells the story of a free chicken coupon that worked far too well.

01

Sell advertising as a journey

Aim for annual commitments instead of one-off campaigns. IndoorMedia sees at least 6 to 7 times ROI once tape customers renew for a second year.

02

Advertise where your competition isn't

Digital is getting more crowded and more expensive. Offline channels that still offer targeting, exposure and repetition can be a local business's first best option.

03

Fix conversion before scaling ads

Eric's order is loyalty, advertise, convert, then nurture. If paid traffic lands on a page that doesn't convert, the ad spend won't help.

04

Put a profitable qualifier on every offer

A free meal coupon with no conditions flooded a fried chicken restaurant. Attach a purchase, like a drink or fries, so the response doesn't put you out of business.

In their words

Some brilliant ideas

On why grocery receipts did digital's job long before digital

“All those nice things that you hear about digital, in terms of targeting, exposure, and repetition, we've been doing since 89.”

, Jump to this moment

When I go to Google and Gemini answers my question, rather than seeing web pages and web results, it's a major problem for local business.

If I'm advertising and they're landing someplace that's not converting, it's not really going to help you.

Full transcript

Introduction

[0:00:15] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: So, welcome to Pathmonk Presents, where we talk with growth and marketing leaders about what's actually working right now. I'm Adrian, your host, and today I'm joined by Eric Shafer. Chief Transformation Officer at IndoorMedia. Hi, Eric, how's it going?

[0:00:33] ERIC SHAFER: It's going good, Adrian, how are you?

[0:00:35] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Doing pretty well, doing pretty well today. Thanks for asking. So, what is that your company does?

Ads on grocery receipts and shopping carts

[0:00:42] ERIC SHAFER: So, we have been, for the past 37 years, we have been helping local businesses connect with their neighbors. By advertising at grocery stores. So, we have local businesses, like, quick-serve restaurants, fast casual, hair and nail salons, things like that. Also, a lot of insurance, real estate agents, people like that, all local businesses that really have a very tight targeted market. And then they advertise on the back of the grocery store receipt with a coupon, so that's a direct response ad, or they do branding ads on the shopping carts themselves.

[0:01:19] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Oh, interesting. So, I guess that you have kind of a two-sided marketplace, in a way that you need to contact the small businesses at the same time, you need to go for a grocery source, right? So,

[0:01:33] ERIC SHAFER: Sorry, just to correct that, so the grocery stores aren't our customer. Okay. They're… they're our channel. So, we distribute through the grocery stores. We actually manufacture the register tape itself.

[0:01:47] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Oh, God.

[0:01:47] ERIC SHAFER: So we produce the registered tape, we print the ads on the back. We have agreements with the grocery stores and contracts in order to do the advertising. So, one of the things that's… two things that are very interesting, I think, about the company. For a marketing company, we manufacture enough register tape to go from the Earth to the Moon and back. Five times every year. Wow. And then, we're also, because we have all this press capacity, we're also the largest fortune cookie printer Okay. fortunes in the.

[0:02:22] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Right. Kind of, ask for any, any money in exchange of a tape on the, the, the paper.

[0:02:31] ERIC SHAFER: So… so we… so we do, so it's a… it's an agreement, so the… basically, most grocery store chains get a discount on the tape.

[0:02:41] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Okay. Right.

[0:02:42] ERIC SHAFER: For the honor of… or for the privilege of us being able to advertise on it.

[0:02:46] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Right.

[0:02:46] ERIC SHAFER: If they also do carts, then it's… we give them more of an incentive.

[0:02:50] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Right, right.

[0:02:50] ERIC SHAFER: Really remove a cost item off their bottom line.

[0:02:54] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Sure. So, in terms of, like, a percentage of a business that represents the advertising compared to the selling of, you know, the paper. What is bigger? What's,

[0:03:07] ERIC SHAFER: Oh, advertising's much bigger. So, our… we are around, so depending on how you do it, probably around $120 million in revenue. Right. 90 of that is advertising.

Reaching local businesses: sales team vs digital

[0:03:20] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Right, right, right, right. So, I'm wondering here about, you know, your go-to-market strategy for the small businesses, because I guess that you are, in a way. all across America, if I'm correct. Yes, yeah. So, it's a very granulated, in a way, approach, right? So, you need to get to the towns, to get to the villages, to get to the big cities, then get in contact with a ton of different people, like you mentioned before, like the nasal lands. cyber shops, you know what I mean, whatever. How do you structure that?

[0:03:53] ERIC SHAFER: So, it's interesting. So, for the majority of the history of the company, we have relied on our sales team. So, we have a sales team of about 500 people. Okay. And they are spread all over the country. We do Canada as well, so we're at 9,000 grocery stores. For the most part, it is, metropolitan areas that we're targeting. So, it's been… it's been a cold calling. I will tell you, finding, an audience of quick-serve, you know, either franchisees or independent Mexican restaurant owners is about as difficult as anything on the net. I mean. We have been… we have struggled for years trying to get the right audiences together, and it's only been in the last couple years that our paid marketing strategies for digital

have actually really paid off to connecting with those people. They're just… It just turns out that, you know, if you're… if you own a single restaurant, the chances that you've created a LinkedIn profile and said, restaurant owner, is not very likely. And so.

[0:05:03] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Middle to none, yeah.

[0:05:04] ERIC SHAFER: Yeah, yes. And so… so we have sales teams that literally just call them up, and they do it the old school style. So we've been very successful at that. We… we have, over the past two years, so our… Our digital channels have been our strongest channels, by far our best sales reps, but not by much. In terms of producing leads. Over the past 2 years, we have really upped our game. We're spending close to $100,000 a month in digital advertising now. And that has really accelerated. So, you know, we… our… our, inbound digital marketing, from just a source, perspective is probably beating our top, say, 7 to 8 sales reps, which is a huge accomplishment for us. Oh, yeah. We plan to get bigger.

[0:05:57] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Sure, absolutely, that sounds…

Attribution and the shark of advertising

[0:06:00] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Super great. I'm wondering about the offer that you have for your customers, right, the adverts? Do you include any kind of a tracking between, you know, the particular piece of paper and the restaurant, or everything like that? Because at the end, one of the most difficult things, especially for small ones, is to track their performance and make sure that that's working for them.

[0:06:26] ERIC SHAFER: Right? Getting great attribution is…

[0:06:29] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Yes.

[0:06:30] ERIC SHAFER: That's one of the challenges, right? So, we're actually doing a little refinement to our advertising, sorry, to our brand. And it's something I've been saying for years, but we're gonna actually formalize it and put it into all of our branding material. I think of us as the shark of advertising, and the reason that is, is because the shark has been around for millennium. They are perfectly fit for purpose, because they do the exact thing that they need to do. So, especially when you talk about the register tape program, because it's a coupon. It has fantastic attribution, because you know exactly which coupons have been used. It has fantastic targeting, because we know that every grocery store pulls its customers from within two and a half miles.

We know that, those grocery store visits are, 2 to 3 times a week. Actually, it's about 1.5 for the pri- or 1.7 for the primary, shopper and 1.5 for the secondary. So, all those nice things that you hear about digital, in terms of targeting, exposure, and repetition, we've been doing since 89. And so, for the tape side especially, it has been, that ROI has been part of our sales pitch. From the get-go Okay. For our cartvertizing solution, because it is a brand ad, and because those customers tend to be customers who have infrequent business transactions. So, when you talk about a realtor. The average turnover in the United States is 7 years for a home. So…

They're not getting that regular repetition for somebody. So, because they have that brand advertising, it's like so much many other brand advertising. It's, are they getting known? Are they hearing back that they're being seen? And what else do they do with it? So it's more of a traditional, brand ad that, you know, how much is a Super Bowl commercial worth? Who knows? People pay lots of money for it, and we know that successful businesses advertise.

Local media trends and zero-click search

[0:08:44] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Check. Yeah, I'm wondering about, you know, the trends that you're seeing in the market, especially for local advertising, and how is your solution comparing to other, like, a radio, or, you know, like a broadcasting, local TVs? How do you see the industry, and what are the trends and the future opportunities?

[0:09:08] ERIC SHAFER: Yeah, so I think those 3 things that we just talked about are… Incredibly important for any kind of ad, that you have the right targeting, the right exposure, and the right repetition. Our comparison to, radio or mass media, and traditional print has always been that our targeting is so much better because the grocery store has that geographic targeting that's always there. We know we're getting placed in the hand, literally in the hand of the customer. In the United States, almost every grocery store gives a receipt. I know in Europe, that's very different, right? A lot of options to not have receipts, and you might get a little printout or so.

[0:09:48] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Yes. I mean, not really. We are enforcing it for tax fraud purposes, you know, to avoid it. So, it's being a kind of a requirement, so I guess it's pretty much the same thing in the US as well.

[0:10:02] ERIC SHAFER: Okay, sure, so that's awesome. So, so with that targeting, exposure, and repetition, that's where we've always really excelled above traditional media. When you start looking at digital. The digital landscape, and I just gave a presentation, in all hands to the We were talking about what the landscape is looking like, especially with generative AI on the rise, and we started talking about things like. the volume of search on Google has gone up 163% in the past 2 years. So, the largest website on the planet has had its volume double. 1.5 times. In the last 2 years. And of those, right just as of recently, 43% of those are zero-click.

Weird.

[0:10:58] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Yep.

[0:10:59] ERIC SHAFER: So, what that tells me is that for our local business, where a website was really important, SEO was important. Making sure that you could do that. they're really facing a challenge in that we are producing all these walled gardens. When I go to Google and Gemini answers my question, rather than seeing web pages and web results, it's a major problem for local business. It's much more bifurcated as well, when you see, I have to think about my Instagram audience versus Facebook versus Google versus, wherever else they might be doing regular display ads and whatever. So the digital landscape is becoming increasingly competitive.

For where you're putting your dollars, and more expensive. Yep. So… What we've really been honing in on, and as we've looked at our two core products, our register tape advertising and our cart advertising. What we've seen is that Those things are places where your competition isn't. You still get those things that make up such a great ad, repetition, exposure, and and… targeting. And we… we really feel very strongly that this is your first best advertising option. And… If you are within the right distance from a grocery store, and you're the right category, we have an excellent use case for you, and a great ROAS to give you that profitability on your advertising.

[0:12:35] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Yeah, absolutely. Sorry for the video, it went off, I don't know what happened.

Digital Boost and multi-channel bundles

[0:12:40] ERIC SHAFER: That's okay.

[0:12:42] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: I'm wondering, you know, you are so focused on this kind of attribution model, and all the physical placement for the tape and, you know, tracking whatever is happening. I think that that's a marvelous. What about the entry point that you can enjoy in terms of… you know, cross-selling or upselling for the customers and the advertisers that you… you work with, right? I'm… I'm wondering if this is something that you have considered at all. years of experience and the strategic questions that you posed within the company, like, is there a follow-up in terms of advertising beyond the physical and tangible receipt?

[0:13:26] ERIC SHAFER: Yes, so we are, so we introduced display advertising, we call it Digital Boost, about 3 years ago. And have really just started to get a really good foundation on that side. So we offer very competitive CPM for your display advertising. we love pairing that with your print ad. So we geocenter on the grocery store itself. Right. So now we're getting a multi-channel approach for customers that are going there, seeing your ad, either on the shopping cart or on the tape, but now also on the internet.

[0:14:03] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Right.

[0:14:03] ERIC SHAFER: And that's been a very… we've had a lot of success with that. Some people… we've got sales reps that are only offering bundles now.

[0:14:12] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Right.

The four legs: loyalty, advertise, convert, nurture

[0:14:12] ERIC SHAFER: that omni-channel approach. So we're very excited about that. As I look through… well, as I look towards the future, and especially talking about generative AI and how that's going to work, and it's one of the things that has got me thinking about Pathmonk recently. And when you guys reached out, I was like, oh, you know, this is actually part of, kind of, a four… Four-legged chair for us. I think the way advertising's gonna look for local business going forward is, one, is loyalty programs, because Current customer is your best customer, and we're offering… we have a new offering we call, because I told you we're all in on sharks, we call it Loyalty Shark.

Okay. And a loyalty program, that… Really aims to change behavior, not just give discounts. Not just the rewards for spending. So I think it is loyalty. Advertising, which can be obviously with us, it could be paid advertising, however that's gonna look. Nurturing, especially for those businesses that are, don't have frequent customers, because you're going to capture them with loyalty, so if you are an insurance agent, how do I… It's not really loyalty, it's how do I keep them… keep those happy customers and people, those prospects.

[0:15:35] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: It's about retention, right?

[0:15:37] ERIC SHAFER: Well, and top of mind. You know, so for a realtor, it may be 3 years before I actually hear from you. So staying top of mind is really important. That's the part I consider nurture. And then, of course, the last leg of that, and this is where I think Pathmonk comes in so heavily, is converting.

[0:15:56] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Oh, yeah.

[0:15:56] ERIC SHAFER: We've got to go… you've got to have all four of those legs really running. I do think there's priority. I think you start with loyalty, or referral program. advertise, convert, because if I'm advertising and they're landing someplace that's not converting, it's not really going to help you. And then, once they convert, either into a MQL or an SQL, nurture.

[0:16:20] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Right.

[0:16:21] ERIC SHAFER: That is the model for us. I mean, that is what local businesses really have to do today. It's not enough to just open up and be there. You're going to be at the bottom of the market.

[0:16:33] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Yeah, in a way, you are the perfect mark… the perfect partner to supply all those services, right? Because… Then the distribution becomes so easy that if you make it work, and it's sustainable.

The ROI of receipt and cart ads

[0:16:47] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: you're going to be a long-term partner for everyone around the grocery shops in which you distribute your tickets, right? I mean, it's a… I wonder if you have any kind of a… Return on investment, or any figure, any, you know, reference that the audience could relate to when it comes to You know, your efficiency and how much value you are creating for the customers that you work with.

[0:17:14] ERIC SHAFER: Yeah, so we… we do a lot of that analysis. We… we've got a… We look for testimonials all the time for our customers, we try to data mine, and especially on the tape side. because they have such great attribution, we can literally go in and figure out their… pretty much their exact ROI. What we see on the tape side is that if somebody will stay with the program, and we really work… shoot for annual contracts, because we have to get, especially for a lot of local businesses, they have to understand that advertising is a journey. It's not something that we're… it's not a transaction. You're not buying customers, you're buying influence.

So if we get somebody to renew at the end of the year, that's… from that second year on, we almost inevitably see a minimum of a 6 to 7 times ROI on the ad.

[0:18:07] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Oh. Okay.

[0:18:09] ERIC SHAFER: That's not to say that we'd have people that it doesn't work for, and for a variety of reasons, and, you know, I mean, advertising's tough, so… but if we see a successful customer, they will have a 6 to 7 ROI. For our shopping cart branding ads, it's a little more difficult, but by and large, what we see is that one influenced deal will usually pay for the ad that year.

The free chicken meal story

[0:18:34] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Right. I don't know if you have had any kind of a, you know, one-of-a-kind cycle story in which you have, for example, a restaurant that it has so much… let's say, potential with a grocery store close to them, that they follow you along to another grocery store when they see an opportunity, because, you know, the people are going to get the coupons and the attributions so that they can, in a way, you know, proliferate following your lead.

[0:19:02] ERIC SHAFER: Well, I do have a funny story that's some… not quite that scenario, but it is a great story. It's about a fried chicken restaurant. And they were doing, every door direct mail, so they were sending out flyers, and their offer was, a free chicken meal. It was, like, $6 value.

[0:19:24] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Right.

[0:19:25] ERIC SHAFER: And they had no qualifiers on it. Just a free chicken meal come in. And they had had success with this, and they were pleased with it, and our sales rep got in there and said, okay, let's… hey, you know, we can do this, and we can do it for a little cheaper than you're even doing it. And they said, well, we want to run the same offer, and we said, you can't. You can't. And they said, why? And they said, you're gonna get overwhelmed. It's gonna be cra… you don't understand how many of these coupons we're giving out. Right. And he said, no, no, this has worked for me. Well, he did it. He went through the roof. He called us trying to get us to pull the receipts. He called the grocery store.

[0:20:02] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: He…

[0:20:03] ERIC SHAFER: stacks of receipts, it looked like New York with buildings, with all these stacks of receipts everywhere. He had people lined around the building. We said, you've got to sell it with, you know, buy a drink, buy fries, whatever. You've got to make it profitable for you.

[0:20:17] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: You're gonna go out of business otherwise, right?

[0:20:22] ERIC SHAFER: And that's exactly right. He's gonna… he's gonna lose 10 cents a meal and make it up on volume.

[0:20:29] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Yeah, definitely. Okay, so, in a way, you prevented a customer for being bankrupted in a way, right?

[0:20:37] ERIC SHAFER: We advised as best we could, and then he did what he was gonna do, and then we got him on the right path, and he's been a loyal customer for a long time since then, but yeah, it was… it was interesting.

Where to find IndoorMedia

[0:20:48] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Yeah, amazing. So, Eric, thank you so much for coming on. I would like to ask you, you know, to share, the directions for anyone with a small business in the U.S. that is looking forward to, you know, get a super… Advertising platform in terms of, like, tickets and everything, track the attribution, and also explore the digital advertising that you're bringing along, which is super interesting.

[0:21:14] ERIC SHAFER: Yeah, well, thanks, I, it's been… I've enjoyed it.

[0:21:17] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Yep. So, do you want to, you know, share the details, just to reach you out, or your company, in case there's someone interested in following along? Yeah.

[0:21:26] ERIC SHAFER: Yeah, the best way to go, there's two things you can do. Go to indoormedia.com, exactly as it's spelled. That's the easiest way. We do have a podcast designed specifically for, local business owners, so it's called the Bounce Point. Nice. And you can find it on all the different platforms, and if you go to our site, I think you can find it there, too. But we really talk about the challenges for local business, and what we really like about it is that I owned a local business, our marketing director owned a Small advertising agency, and one of our other content generators is actually part owner in an improv theater.

And so we all come with experience of managing local businesses, trying to advertise market, and we talk about the challenges and what that looks like. So it's a lot of fun, we just have a good time, really.

[0:22:16] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Perfect. So, thank you, Eric, and let's stay in touch.

Be a guest on Pathmonk Presents

Got a growth story worth sharing? Tell it on the show.

We talk with founders and marketing leaders about what actually moves their pipeline. If you’ve built something other marketers can learn from, we’d like to hear it.

How it works
  1. 01
    Apply

    Tell us who you are and the story you’d bring to the show.

  2. 02
    We get in touch

    We review every application and reach out if it’s a fit.

  3. 03
    Record your episode

    A remote conversation, published as video, audio and a full transcript.