Fans still want a printed ticket, and teams are getting it wrong
Do fans still want commemorative tickets? Matt Wolff of Ticket Time Machine shares how guerrilla marketing, LinkedIn and referrals grow a no-budget brand.
“Who you know is very important, but who knows you is maybe even more important.”
at
- Company
- Ticket Time Machine, a commemorative product company
- Speciality
- Souvenir and animated tickets, badges and lanyards
- Works with
- Teams, leagues, events and conferences (mostly B2B)
- Deliverable
- Free design and print-ready keepsakes, mostly in standard shapes
- Growth engine
- Guerrilla marketing, referrals, LinkedIn and Instagram
Too long, didn’t listen?
Matt Wolff founded Ticket Time Machine because he is a fan who lost something he loved: the printed ticket. His company makes souvenir and animated tickets, badges and lanyards. It sells mostly B2B to teams, leagues, events and conferences, offers free design, and sticks mostly to standard shapes because a custom die costs $750 to $1,000.
With no marketing budget, Matt grows the company through guerrilla marketing, referrals and a personal, non-automated presence on LinkedIn and Instagram, where the algorithm keeps showing him events he never knew existed. He argues that teams overprice commemorative tickets at $30, names ghosting as his biggest obstacle, and explains why being known can matter more than who you know.
Focus on who knows you
Matt argues that being known may matter even more than who you know. Show up at events, post consistently and let people hear about you from others.
Use social feeds to find leads
Matt gets little engagement on Instagram, but the algorithm keeps showing him events he never knew existed. Use the feed for prospecting, not only for broadcasting.
Don't take silence as a no
His biggest obstacle is ghosting from cold contacts, people he has quoted and existing customers. Build follow-up into your process, and check that you are reaching the right person.
Make every marketing dollar count
Matt competes with no formal marketing budget against companies that are 100 years old and pay to play. Authentic, founder-led outreach can win where you can't outspend the competition.
Some brilliant ideas
“Not a lot of interaction and engagement on that, but what it does for me is it sends me a ton of leads, events that I never even knew occurred because the algorithm is seeing what I'm doing and showing me other stuff.”
I don't take silence as a no, and so that takes up a lot of my time.
They're out there selling them for $30. I don't think it should be $30 for a commemorative ticket. I think if you priced it right, you'd sell a lot more.
Full transcript
Introduction
[0:00:14] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: So, welcome to Pathmonk Presents, where we talk with growth and marketing leaders about what's actually working right now. I'm Adrian, your host, and today I'm joined by Matt Wolff. Founder at the Ticket Time Machine. Great to have you on, Matt.
MATT WOLFF: Yeah, thanks for having me. How's it going?
What Ticket Time Machine makes
[0:00:36] MATT WOLFF: Everything's going well. Just, plugging along and trying to build the empire. Sure. So, first of all, what is a Ticket Time Machine? And, in your own words, What do you do? Ticket Time Machine is a commemorative… product. company. We started out with tickets, but we do products, we do all different types of products. Animated is our differentiator, but old school tickets as well. This is what it started out as, doing a souvenir tickets, and then badges, and lanyards, and… Pretty much anything that has to do with events that people want to commemorate.
Okay. So, I'm wondering, like, those are kind of a, you know, like, people buying them, or it's more about, like, a company's, that they want to remembrate something? How does it work?
MATT WOLFF: Yeah, so we're mostly B2B, 4C. They either are part of VIP packages, or giveaways, or possibly for purchase as well. We don't have licensing for much. We have a few licenses and some partnerships.
Free design and the cost of custom dies
[0:01:51] MATT WOLFF: But mostly you're selling directly to the team, the league, the event, the conference, and they're using it for the customer. But, so mostly B2B at this point. Okay, so at this point, are you taking care of the creative design of the different tickets, or is it your customer who's presenting you, like, what they want? How does it work? Yeah, we're probably maybe 50-50 on that. We offer free design, so we don't charge to do the design, and a lot of people want to take advantage of that, and then some people have a very clear idea of what they want, and they send in a design.
MATT WOLFF: We'll give them tips and pointers if we think it could be better or what might not look good, but generally they're, you know, we go with what they've designed and just put it into our templates so it'll work and be print-ready. Right, so you are manufacturing those things, I guess. You have a variety of styles and shapes that you can put to the market, is that correct? Yeah, so we have… we have designs that we do, and templates that we do, and then you could always… create a new one. That involves a die, which is an added cost, you know, somewhere between $750 to $1,000.
MATT WOLFF: So you're gonna… if you're gonna want to create your own custom, which we've done before, you're gonna want to have quite a bit of volume on there, so it… it sort of offsets the cost of the die, or, you know, let someone else pay for the die, and then you just kind of use what's… what else is out there, but I would say most of the orders are just standard, you know, we have rectangle, square, just standard size and shape, just because of the added expense.
Guerrilla marketing and who knows you
[0:03:40] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Okay, good. So, I'm… I'm wondering, about the fans and, you know, the team, the venue partners. How did they find you? Like, yeah.
MATT WOLFF: Yeah, so we do… I do a pretty good job of trying to get visibility, whether that's on LinkedIn. Instagram, all of the socials, but also a lot of boots on the ground, at events, wearing my Ticket Time Machine branded, passing out free tickets to an event that I'm at, and word of mouth, of course, is always going to be the best way, so referrals. But it's a lot of, I guess, old-school guerrilla marketing. You know, founder out on the streets, peddling the product, and just trying to get people to know who you are. I think that's… who you know is very important, but who knows you
MATT WOLFF: is maybe even more important, and there's a lot more people who know who you are that you don't even know that they know who you are. So it's just about, you know, getting out there, getting visibility. content, joining, networking groups, and just, you know, it's interesting, I've had people… you know, send me stuff that… they say there was a post, and then they mention Ticket Time Machine, or they went to a box office, and they said, hey, you can try Ticket Time Machine, and that's the result of either me going and talking to those people, or, you know, someone seeing it elsewhere.
Yeah, it's about, like, building your brand, right? So, working day and night for it. I guess that, you know, as long as you keep a good reliability and quality at the end.
Repeat customers and quality over profit
[0:05:25] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: A customer that would you win today. Could be, you know, asking you for a match for 20 years.
MATT WOLFF: Damn. Take care. We do have a… we do have a lot of repeat customers. Right. And then we have some customers that, have moved on. some, maybe to our fault, where something happened, you know, some of that stuff is out of our control. We do the best we can to make the customer happy, go above and beyond, and there's several occasions where we've spent considerable money to make the customer happy. Friday. and they actually moved on from us. I'm always going to want to do what's best for the customer and the fans. You know, I built the company because I'm a fan.
MATT WOLFF: obviously, I need to make money as a company, but I don't put the profit before the quality or the… Absolutely. Obviously, within reason, there's just gotta be… it's gotta make sense, and…
Social media as a lead engine
[0:06:25] MATT WOLFF: So we're trying to help enforcement. before you, you mentioned about this, you know, like, social, I guess that for a product like you, where there are many fans and, you know, venues and… sport team, or whatever it is, like, it has an impact to be on the… on the, on the socials, and in TikTok, and Instagram, and, you know, like, this… this kind of a high, high-paced, performance. Is that something that you are, you know, like a… paying an agency for running, or are you running… running it on your own? How does it work? Yeah, I don't… I do it all myself, and I have interns that have done it. The social media…
MATT WOLFF: I put out a lot of content, LinkedIn, probably mostly, but also posting a lot on Instagram, which automatically posts to Facebook. Not a lot of interaction and engagement on that, but what it does for me is it sends me a ton of leads, events that I never even knew occurred because the algorithm is seeing what I'm doing and showing me other stuff. So, I think that, right now, as of today, is the strongest, benefit of social media, is just finding out all these events. That I didn't even know existed. And, sure, I think that people are seeing it. People come up to me all the time and say, man, I love seeing your stuff, or you got… you're everywhere, I'm seeing… I'm seeing your stuff, so… that's great, we need to increase that. I don't…
MATT WOLFF: You know, everything I do is authentic and genuine, and I know there's a lot of AI automation, and there's companies out there that can do it. Yeah. nobody is going to be able to speak to it the way that I am right now, and, you know, I have the, the blessing and a curse of being small enough where I can still do that. Right. My goal is to be big enough where I can't do that anymore, and have to rely on some of that, but as of now, everything I do is… I don't have any email lists, every email I send is me, every LinkedIn message is me.
Printed tickets in a digital world
[0:08:28] MATT WOLFF: You know, it's not automated. Yep, absolutely. So, I'm… I'm wondering now about this, like, a new kind of a digital trends, even in ticketing, because I see an opportunity for vendors like you to capitalize on this nostagia and, you know, different designs, the ability to touch a thing and have real tangible thing that is not going to allow you to enter in a particular place, but also give you kind of a souvenir for the time being, right? So, I would like to have your opinion on that, and how you position your brand differently from, like, digital ticketing platforms, or, like, a mobile
you know, QRs and things like that.
MATT WOLFF: Yeah, well, that's what we're doing. We're keeping the printed memory alive. I'm a fan, it's something that was taken away from me, it's something that I want, and I know other people want. It might not be at the huge level that you know, I think it… In some cases, it doesn't move the needle for these teams and events, and that's why they don't offer it at all. And then the other teams and events and leagues have started to do commemorative tickets, which is great, I love it, that's what we do, we can help. I think they're not doing it well.
MATT WOLFF: I think they're overpriced, I think it's a… it's a so-so product, you know, something… if it's something that you can just print at home yourself, or go, you know, go on Etsy and someone can do it. then I don't think it's a great product. I think there should be something either unique or genuine about it, and it's overpriced, you know, they're out there selling them for $30, I don't think it should be. $30 for a commemorative ticket, I think if you priced it right, you'd sell a lot more. There's a lot of different ways that I would do it, but I'm glad that we're doing it, that it's a thing. It's not, hey, should we be doing this?
MATT WOLFF: Yeah, so that's really, you know, but it's… it's disappointing that some teams actually have the stock right there, and the printers, and I just encountered it this past weekend. I went to 4 different games, 2 of them, they just wouldn't print. It's just like, I know you print, it's not like you don't print for other people. You're not getting a ton of people asking, so why wouldn't you… why wouldn't you do it? And I think that's… you know, it's bad customer service. They're pointing me to this commemorative ticket, which is not a good thing, and it's $30. I want the real thing, you know, or something that looks like the real thing.
MATT WOLFF: And so, again, grateful that we're… that they're starting to do it. But it could be done better, and that's where I'm trying to… to come in.
How customers reach out
[0:11:06] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Absolutely. So I'm… I'm wondering now about, like, you said before, like, if people know you and, you know, they recognize you with all the things that you've done. and also your branding. How do they reach you? do they kind of get into your website, and then, you know, look around and see, okay, so this is the guy who's, you know, doing this running, or it is more like an Instagram message, or LinkedIn, or maybe a partner that it's just, you know, referral or something.
MATT WOLFF: Yeah, Murray. Oh, sweet. email. Mostly emails. The website's under construction, so it points to…
MATT WOLFF: something called Ringpin. It's a dynamic QR code that will point and give you a lot of different options where you can see our catalogs and some other stuff. Okay. and reach out to me, but mostly email. I do get occasionally stuff online from people who saw something, either a post or saw that someone else did stuff, and tagged us, so… but mostly email.
Ghosting, old rivals and no budget
[0:12:14] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Okay, okay. So, you know, I wanted to ask you as well about the largest problem that you see, day-to-day, in your… maybe in your work, or, you know, in the industry, something that you… You would like to share something, like, it's a big problem that you would like to have, like, a solved or cleared away?
MATT WOLFF: I always say that the biggest… Obstacle to me… getting to the Empire is the… is… ghosting. People… Okay. Either not replying, or not doing what they say they're gonna do, and. Alright. I'm talking about a cold email, I'm talking about customers, I'm talking about people who I've done proofs for, people who have been quoted already. To me, that's the number one thing
MATT WOLFF: I don't take silence as a no, and so that takes up a lot of my time. Probably reaching out to someone, and they might not even be the right person without knowing. Yeah. Bonds. 100%. Fair enough. Yeah, I fully agree with that. Actually, I'm one of the guys who replies no a lot. You know, I say no many times, because I love to receive no's instead of that silence that you mentioned. I think it's important. Yeah, the other thing is, I'm a, you know, a small company, relatively new, there's competitors that have been around for 100 years, and so they have…
MATT WOLFF: the name recognition, they have relationships, and sometimes people are… I keep hearing people, well, we've been using these people forever. I think you should try and find out what's new, you know, hold them accountable, make sure they're treating you right with regards to the quality of the product, the price, the turnaround, customer service, all of that. And then the other thing is, in this day and age, there's a lot of pay-for-play, and so these companies have bigger marketing budgets. I actually don't have a marketing budget, so I have to look at everything and say, can I do it? Can I afford it? All of that. So everything is over budget.
MATT WOLFF: Technically, right? I mean, obviously, I spend money, so I… but I have to make sure each dollar counts and isn't wasted. So, those are probably the biggest things, obstacles. right now, and just, you know, by continuing to get my name out there, and getting more customers, I think, Yeah, I think that that's… that's the way I'm gonna do it, short. Sure. winning the lottery and having an influx of money that I could just throw at this.
LinkedIn as the one source to keep
[0:14:49] ADRIAN GARCIA RAMOS: Okay, so last question. This is about for an audience, right? And, the idea is to separate the noise from the signal, in terms of all the things that are… in a way, shouting at us every day, like, TikTok, YouTube, you know, LinkedIn, many, many different things. So, if there was just one single source. that you would use to run your business and have kind of an intuition or some information about the market, what… That service, would be…
MATT WOLFF: Yeah, I mean, LinkedIn jumps out to me as the obvious choice for me, because I'm on it a lot, and I think it's a good way to connect and to really figure out who's who.
Okay.
MATT WOLFF: Instagram would probably be a close second, just because you're always seeing the new stuff, but for me, LinkedIn, I think, if I had to get rid of everything else, I think that's been the most useful for me. I also… I started a group to help people find work. It's called Open to Work and Looking. We're over 5,000 members. People are posting… I share other people's posts, and there's a ton of people out there who are just posting lots of jobs every week, so it's been helpful. I think that's the best way to actually get connected, and I have 10, 13,000 connections, and I'm trying to connect with people, but again, not hearing back from them, not getting an opportunity.
Right.
MATT WOLFF: I mean, not everything needs to be sales, right? And I agree with that. Sometimes. you need to cut to the chase, like, you want to talk about the weather? Fine, but let's talk about it while I share what we… how we can help you. And so, you know, that's the big issue for me. But LinkedIn has been great. There's a lot of… it needs to improve. There's things that could be better about it, but it would be easy choice for me. 100%. Okay, so, Matt, thanks, you know, for coming to the show. I just wanted to pass you the word in terms of, like,
If you want the people, you know, the fans, the venue managers, and all the people looking at this, show, if you want to share your details, and… the literature of your business for… for them to find you. Go on.
MATT WOLFF: I'm about as accessible a person as you'll ever meet. I reply to everyone You can find me at Matt at TicketTimeMachine.com is my email. You can find me on LinkedIn, Instagram, Facebook. Go to our website, scan our QR code, which should be easy to find. writing. And I'll reply. Whether I can help you, you can help me, or you just want to chat about something, I'm happy to share what I know.
Great! So, thanks for joining, today, Matt. And, let's stay in… let's stay in touch!
Got a growth story worth sharing? Tell it on the show.
We talk with founders and marketing leaders about what actually moves their pipeline. If you’ve built something other marketers can learn from, we’d like to hear it.
- 01Apply
Tell us who you are and the story you’d bring to the show.
- 02We get in touch
We review every application and reach out if it’s a fit.
- 03Record your episode
A remote conversation, published as video, audio and a full transcript.